WeiGao Transmission
Email: sales@wgt.net.cn
Language
通栏图2
tonglantu.jpg
Home / News / How to classify reducer gear pitting corrosion: criteria for rejecting pitting, expansion and spalling - Hangzhou Weigao Transmission

How to classify reducer gear pitting corrosion: criteria for rejecting pitting, expansion and spalling - Hangzhou Weigao Transmission

Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 24-10-2026      Origin: Site

Inquire

facebook sharing button
twitter sharing button
line sharing button
wechat sharing button
linkedin sharing button
pinterest sharing button
whatsapp sharing button
sharethis sharing button

Opening the inspection hole of the reducer , the dense layer of small pits on the tooth surface often leads to two completely opposite treatments on site: one requires the machine to stop and replace the gear pair on the spot, and the other says 'the running-in period is normal' and then runs for another year. Both judgments can be wrong. Whether the reducer gear pitting should be treated or not depends not on the number of pits, but on three energy numbers: the diameter of the pit, the ratio of the area to the effective tooth surface, and whether the depth of the pit penetrates the hardened layer.

Pitting corrosion is the result of contact fatigue and is a progressive damage. It actually gives a period of time that can be used to arrange spare parts and downtime windows. Whether this window is used or wasted depends on whether the "pitting corrosion" can be graded on site, rather than generally saying "pitting on the tooth surface". The following is in the order of interpretation: first distinguish the type of damage, then look at the stage, and then fall to the third level of rejection criteria, number specifications, acceleration reasons, repair boundaries and re-inspection rhythm.

1. First, distinguish whether it is pitting corrosion, micropitting corrosion or gluing.

The three injuries look similar in photos, but the treatment directions are completely different. The price of misjudgment is not small: if you treat gluing as pitting corrosion and continue to run, the tooth surface will be torn in a large area within dozens of hours; if you treat micro pitting corrosion as macro pitting corrosion, it will be a waste of money.

Injury type

Appearance features

Typical causes

Key points for interpretation

Micropitting

The tooth surface is gray, matte, and loses its metallic luster. The pit depth is usually less than 20 μm and the edges are smooth.

Insufficient oil film, low speed and heavy load, large tooth surface roughness, hardened grinding gears are common

It needs to be magnified for observation. It feels astringent when touched with fingers; it is a precursor to macro pitting corrosion.

Macropitting

The pit walls are steep, the edges are sharp, and the shape is irregular. The starting points of cracks can be seen at the bottom of the pit.

Contact stress exceeds fatigue limit, local high point contact

Measurable diameter and depth, can be classified according to area

glue (tear)

Grooves along the sliding direction, material transfer, shiny adhesive marks, in patches rather than dots

Instantaneous oil film rupture, overloading, insufficient running-in or ungraded loading after overhaul

There is no pit, it is a "groove"; it mostly appears near the tooth top and root.

abrasive wear

The tooth thickness is evenly thinned, the tooth surface has fine parallel scratches, and there are no edge sharp pits.

Oil contamination, filter failure, foreign particles

Measure tooth thickness and backlash to see the trend of oil iron content

2. Four stages of reducer gear pitting corrosion: from pitting to peeling

According to the standards of ANSI/AGMA 1010 and ISO 10825-1, macro pitting corrosion is divided into four segments based on pit diameter and expansion behavior. This classification can guide actions better than "light, medium, and heavy":

Initial pitting corrosion : pit diameter is less than 1 mm, scattered and scattered, mostly appearing in the running-in stage hundreds of hours before putting into operation. The cause is that the high points of the tooth surface are in contact. After the high points are worn away, the load is redistributed, and pitting corrosion often stops on its own, so it is also called non-expanding pitting corrosion. This gear does not require disassembly. Extended pitting : The pit diameter exceeds 1 mm, the pits are connected into a group, and the area is still growing between two inspections. At this time, material loss has begun to change the tooth shape. Sheet corrosion : The area of ​​a single pit is large and shallow, the crack expands in a fan shape from the starting point, and the pit shape is triangular. Spalling : Extended pitting corrosion interconnects to form large pits, the hardened layer is penetrated, steps appear on the tooth surface, and obvious meshing impact and vibration rise during operation.

There is a simple way to judge the stage: repeat the shot at the same tooth position every 250~500 operating hours. If the pit diameter does not change and the area does not expand, it is the initial pitting corrosion; if the area expands, go to the expansion file directly without waiting for it to become a big pit.

Third, the third level of scrapping criteria: turning "Should the machine shut down" into a table?

There are differences in specific figures between industries and manufacturers, but the logic of grading is consistent. The following table combines common calibers into three grades, which can be directly compared on site. Only by using the same caliber on the same equipment each time can we talk about trend comparison.

gear

Appearance and pit diameter

Area ratio

The pit is deep

Disposal action

Level 1 observation operation

Isolated pitting, pit diameter ≤1 mm, edge not sharp

Soft tooth surface<5%, hard tooth surface<1%~2%

<0.05 mm, less than the hardened layer

Repeat shooting every 500 hours to record the tooth number and area; simultaneously check the oil level, oil temperature, and filter element

Level 2 limited intervention

The pit diameter is 1~3 mm, and the pieces are started to be connected.

5%~15% (if the hard tooth surface exceeds 1%~2%, it enters this level)

0.05~0.2 mm, still within the hardened layer

Reduce the time to 250 h for re-inspection; review load and working condition coefficients; prepare gear pairs in advance

Level 3 shutdown replacement

The pit diameter is >3 mm or has been connected to form pits or steps.

>15%~25%, or single tooth high speed grade >20%

>0.2~0.3 mm, or the hardened layer interface has been seen and the crack has extended to the tooth root

Arrange for shutdown and replacement, and do not perform sick operations; check for unbalanced load and lubrication at the same time

Two weighted items that are easily overlooked: one is the location . Pitting corrosion occurs in the tooth root transition zone or close to the tooth end, and the local stress is high, so it should be treated as the previous gear; the other is the gear series . The high-speed stage has high rotation speed and many meshing times per unit time. For the same area ratio, the life margin is much smaller than that of the low-speed stage.

4. How to measure the area without fighting: standards for taking numbers and taking photos

Two interpretations of the same equipment yielded different conclusions. Most of the time, it was not the tooth surface that had changed, but the number-retrieval method that had changed. If the following are solidified into on-site specifications, there will be much less controversy:

Tooth position fixation: Mark and number the tooth ends. Check the same batch of tooth positions each time, and take one place each in the meshing area, near the pitch line, and in the meshing area. Scale : A steel ruler or ruler sticker must be placed in the photo. The pit diameter is converted in pixels. Do not rely on 'it looks like 2 mm'. Magnification: 20~50 times, same light source, same angle, avoid direct flash. Area estimation: Use transparent grid film to paste several grids on the tooth surface, or use image software to segment according to the grayscale threshold. Only the effective tooth surface is counted (about 0.1 times the module below the tooth top and before the transition to the tooth root). Pit depth: Measure the drop from the bottom of the pit to the original tooth surface with a depth dial gauge or lamination method, and note whether there are any cracks around it.

There is another prerequisite: shutdown and cooling before testing . The oil film on the hot tooth surface will reflect light, the boundaries of the pits will be 'blurred', and the depth reading will be too small due to thermal expansion. For models with unsatisfactory inspection hole locations, use an industrial endoscope to insert it, take pictures first, and then interpret.

5. Why pitting corrosion suddenly accelerates: load, oil film and eccentric load

Contact fatigue life is extremely sensitive to load. Contact stress is proportional to the square root of the load, while life is inversely proportional to the sixth power of the contact stress. Converted life is approximately inversely proportional to the cube of the load: if the load only increases by 10%, the life will decrease by about 30%; if the load increases by 20%, the life will decrease by more than half. This explains why 'occasionally excessive' equipment pitting corrosion occurs very quickly, and also explains why the service factor of the reducer cannot be set just enough - it is not a safety factor to prevent fracture, but a margin for fatigue life. It is usually 1.5~2.0 for medium impact conditions.

The oil film is the second line. The surface roughness Ra of grinding gear is about 0.4 μm, and that of hobbing gear is about 1.6 μm. However, the thickness of the elastomeric oil film is only on the order of 1~3 μm. If the roughness is large, the peak points will be in direct contact. When the oil temperature rises from 40℃ to 80℃, the actual viscosity of VG220 gear oil will drop from 220 mm²/s to 20~30 mm²/s, and the film thickness will become thinner. If the oil level is too high, the oil will be stirred and foamed, while if it is too low, it will be sucked out. Both will thin the oil film. This is why the reducer lubricating oil model and oil level should be confirmed according to the installation position.

The third item is partial load. The contact spots in the tooth width direction should be more than 60% and the tooth height direction should be more than 45%; poor coaxiality of the box bearing hole, soft base, and poor coupling alignment will cause the load to press toward the tooth width end, and pitting corrosion will appear at that end. When you see the photo of "pitting corrosion only on one side", check the installation first, don"t doubt the material first.

Article 4 is pollution and craftsmanship. The oil cleanliness is controlled at 18/16/13 level according to ISO 4406, and the filter element accuracy is 10 μm. The entry of abrasive particles into the contact area is a source of stress concentration. The effective hardened layer depth of carburized and quenched parts is about 0.15~0.2 times the modulus, and about 0.8~1.0 mm when the modulus is 5; the tempering color left by grinding burns and excessive residual austenite will cause pitting corrosion to appear in advance.

6. Repair or Replace: Three Boundaries

For gears with soft tooth surfaces (quenched and tempered HB250~300), for first-level pitting corrosion, the loose layer on the surface can be removed by honing or polishing, and the removal amount is controlled to 0.01~0.02 mm. After treatment, the contact spots are re-measured to confirm that the tooth shape has not deviated. Do not perform local repair welding on the hard tooth surface (carburizing and quenching HRC58~62): Welding repair will destroy the local hardness and residual stress distribution, and the heat-affected zone will become a new source of cracks. If the area exceeds 1%~2% and is expanding, it is more secure to replace it in pairs.

Pair replacement is a matter of principle. The pinion has a small number of teeth and a large number of engagements per unit time. Pitting corrosion usually starts from the pinion. If only the pinion is replaced, the contact spots between the new tooth surface and the old tooth surface will not match up, and the new parts are often damaged in a short period of time. The money saved in reducer maintenance is usually paid back in the form of shutdown within half a year.

The acceptance after repair must be recorded in the records: no-load operation for 30 minutes, oil pool temperature rise not exceeding 40 K, vibration speed not exceeding 4.5 mm/s (GB/T 6075.3 early warning line), contact spot tooth width ≥ 60%, tooth height ≥ 45%, and re-inspection after 100 hours of operation to see if there is a secondary increase in abnormal noise and vibration of the reducer .

7. Suppress recurrence: five on-site actions

First, increase the oil product by one level according to the working conditions, from VG220 to VG320 for high temperature or heavy load, and confirm that the oil product is compatible with the sealing material. The second is the filter element and cleanliness. Change the filter element simultaneously when changing the oil. The first oil change should be 300~500 hours, and then 2000~3000 hours or according to the oil test results. The third is to review the load and compare the measured current and torque with the working condition coefficient at Selection. If it exceeds 10% for a long time, it should be modified instead of continuing to observe. The fourth is to correct the eccentric load and redo the alignment and soft foot inspection. The fifth is running-in. The first 100 to 200 hours after maintenance should be loaded in stages of 50%, 75%, and 100%. Do not load it fully at once.

8. Review rhythm table

state

Retest interval

record each time

Upgrade conditions

First level observation

500 h or per month

Tooth number, pit diameter, area %, oil temperature, vibration value

Area increase ≥5 percentage points or pit diameter >1 mm

secondary intervention

250 hours or every two weeks

Same as above, iron content and cleanliness of refueling liquid

The pit depth is >0.2 mm, continuous, and steps appear.

Level three to be replaced

Weekly, limit load

Vibration, temperature, abnormal sound, metal particles in oil

If the vibration exceeds 7.1 mm/s or tooth root cracks appear, the machine will stop.

Taken together, the logic for dealing with reducer gear pitting is very clear: first use appearance to separate pitting from gluing and wear, then classify pits according to pit diameter and area, use a fixed number and re-inspection rhythm to see the trend, and finally talk about repair or replacement. The direct benefit of this is that spare parts can be ordered in advance and downtime can be scheduled into the maintenance plan, instead of waiting for the tooth surface to peel off before rushing to repair it. When Hangzhou Weigao Transmission supplies hard tooth surface reducers, cycloidal pinwheel reducers, worm gear reducers and gear reduction motors, it randomly provides tooth surface inspection record sheets and working condition coefficient value instructions. It can be recalculated based on the actual measured load on site to determine whether to continue observation, repair or complete machine replacement. As a reducer manufacturer, we can also come up with alternative solutions based on the parameters of the original model. If you have tooth surface photos, nameplate parameters and operating hours, please send them over for a free Selection consultation and interpretation.

Latest News

WeiGao Transmission

Weigao Gear Reducer is an alliance group company that integrates research and development, production, sales, and service

+86 400 801 9158

Email: sales@wgt.net.cn;wgt.net.cn@gmail.com
Tel:+86571 85023000

WEIGAO REDUCER

FEEDBACK