Three-step verification method for matching motor power and reducer: torque, speed ratio and inertia - Hangzhou Weigao Transmission

Publish Time: 2026-10-15     Origin: Site

Why "select reducer according to motor power" often goes wrong

In equipment transformation and new production line matching, the matching of motor power and reducer is an aspect that is easy to take for granted and easy to pay for. The practice in many sites is to 'equate a motor with a few kW of reducer'. As a result, after a few months of operation, gear teeth are broken, bearings heat up, and the motor trips frequently. The reason is not complicated: the essence of the reducer is a speed-reducing and torque-increasing device. The motor power is only a condition on the input end. What really determines long-term stable operation is the torque and speed on the output shaft, as well as the impact and thermal balance during start and stop. In other words, the calculation of reducer output torque is the core of matching, and power matching is only its result.

The following three-step verification process comes from Hangzhou Weigao Transmission"s repeatedly verified practices in on-site supporting operations such as transportation, mixing, lifting, and packaging. It can be directly applied with two value tables.

1. Calculate the load side torque accurately first, do not start from the motor power.

What the load requires is not power, but torque and speed. It is known that the required torque T (N·m) and output speed n (r/min) of the working machine are known, and the effective power of the load is converted according to the following formula:

P load = T × n ÷ 9550

For example, if the load torque is 100 N·m and the output speed is 100 r/min, then P load = 100×100÷9550 ≈ 1.05 kW. If the load torque cannot be measured directly, the moment arm method can be used to estimate it (T = F × r). The additional torque generated by the tension force of belt and sprocket transmissions must also be taken into account.

After obtaining the load power, multiply it by the working condition coefficient (also called usage coefficient and service coefficient) to calculate the additional load caused by impact, forward and reverse rotation, and frequent starts and stops. The value of this step directly determines whether Selection is safe or not. Please refer to the following table.

Load case type

Working condition coefficient K reference value

Typical equipment

Continuous, smooth, one-way operation

1.2~1.4

Belt conveyors, fans, centrifugal pumps

Medium impact, material fluctuation

1.4 ~ 1.6

Mixers, packaging machines, small elevators

Big impact, frequent forward and reverse

1.6~2.0

Cranes, winches, reciprocating equipment

Severe impact, heavy load crushing

1.8~2.5

Crusher, ball mill, mining feeding equipment

Industry practice is: the service factor should be no less than 1.25 in situations of continuous operation and stable load, and no less than 1.5 in situations with impact or frequent starts and stops. It is recommended that the service factor be considered above 2.0 for heavy-duty equipment. Foreign samples often have a certain margin built in, so when selecting directly from a sample, you need to check the applicable conditions of the sample.

2. Use the speed ratio to convert the motor side torque to the output shaft.

The torque on the motor side is determined by the power and speed: T motor = 9550 × P motor ÷ n motor . After being transmitted through the reducer, the output shaft torque is:

T output = T motor × i × η (i is the speed ratio, eta is the transmission efficiency)

The speed ratio is determined by the motor speed and the working machine speed: the speed ratio calculation formula of the reducer is i = n motor ÷ n output. Taking the 4-pole asynchronous motor at 1450 r/min and the working machine at 50 r/min as an example, i = 29. In fact, the nearest standard speed ratio (such as 28 or 30) should be selected, and check whether the output speed is still within the allowable range of the process.

Transmission efficiency cannot be converted into 1. The efficiency of different types of reducers is significantly different. The more stages, the lower the efficiency. This is where the output torque is often overestimated.

Reducer type

Single stage efficiency reference value

illustrate

Planetary reducer

0.95 ~ 0.97

Two levels slightly lower, about 0.92 ~ 0.95

Coaxial helical gear (hardened tooth surface)

0.94 ~ 0.97

The number of levels increases and multiplies continuously by level.

Cycloid pin wheel reducer

0.90 ~ 0.94

Two-level or three-level machines are converted by level.

Worm gear reducer

0.70 ~ 0.85

The larger the speed ratio, the lower the efficiency and the greater the heat generation.

When inverting the motor power, use: P motor = P load × K ÷ η . Continuing from the above example, P load is 1.05 kW, K is 1.2, and eta is 0.9, then P motor = 1.05×1.2÷0.9 = 1.4 kW. According to the motor standard power range (0.75/1.1/1.5/2.2/3 kW…), choose 1.5 kW nearby. This is the correct sequence for matching motor power and reducer : torque first, then power.

Falling to the reducer side, the check condition is: the rated output torque of the reducer ≥ calculated torque × working condition coefficient . If there is a peak impact on the load, the peak torque should not exceed the upper limit of the short-term output torque of the reducer.

3. Inertia and starting torque: must be checked under frequent start and stop conditions

The first two steps ensure that the steady-state operation is not bad, and the third step ensures that the start-stop process is not bad. The load inertia is converted to the motor side as J load ÷ i². Excessive inertia ratio will cause oscillation, inaccurate positioning and even tooth surface pitting.

Empirical value: In servo drive applications, the inertia ratio should be controlled within 5:1, and for high-precision positioning it is recommended to be within 3:1; for general-purpose equipment driven by ordinary asynchronous motors, the ratio can be relaxed to 10:1. In addition, the starting torque at full load start is usually 1.5 to 2 times the rated operating torque. The short-term overload capacity of the reducer is generally 2 to 2.5 times the rated torque. When using variable frequency soft start, the starting torque can be limited to 1.2 to 1.5 times, and the Selection margin can be narrowed accordingly. At the same time, don’t forget to check the upper limit of the input speed: high-speed planetary models are usually limited to about 6000 r/min, and excessive speed will significantly increase bearing wear.

4. Two boundary checks that are easily skipped: thermal power and radial load

Qualified mechanical strength does not mean continuous operation. The rated power on the reducer sample is the allowable value of mechanical strength, while the real limit of continuous operation is the thermal power . The smaller value of the two is the actual available power.

The test standards for allowable thermal power are generally an ambient temperature of 20°C, 100% continuous operation per hour, and a lubricating oil equilibrium temperature not exceeding 85 ~ 95°C. Different conditions must be corrected: Calculate thermal power Pct = P load × KT × KW ≤ Pt . Among them, the ambient temperature coefficient KT is about 10 ℃ without cooling measures, and takes 0.88 at 20 ℃, 1.00 at 20 ℃, and 1.15 at 30 ℃. In other words, if a reducer with a nominal thermal power of 10 kW operates continuously in a workshop at 40°C, the actual available thermal power will drop to around 8 kW - derating operation is the norm in high temperatures in summer. When the thermal power is insufficient, the priority is to increase the frame size, and secondly, consider installing a cooling coil.

The other item is the reducer radial load on the output shaft . When the sprocket, pulley, and gear are directly mounted on the output shaft, the radial force is approximately F = 2000 × T ÷ d (d is the shaft extension diameter). The longer the cantilever and the larger the moment arm, the higher the additional load the bearing bears. This must be checked point by point with the allowable radial force curve given in the sample; over-limit use is a typical cause of premature bearing failure and reducer shaft breakage .

5. Three Frequent Misunderstandings and a Checklist

Combined with on-site feedback, there are three places where matching errors are concentrated: first, only the motor power Selection is ignored, and the actual torque is insufficient, causing tooth breakage; second, the transmission efficiency is calculated as 1, and the output torque is overestimated by 5% to 30%, Selection seems to have a margin but is not enough; third, only the steady state is looked at, not the peak value and the environment, and the starting torque, altitude derating (about 3% for every 1000 m increase) and high temperature derating are ignored.

Condensate the above content into a list for easy comparison and checking:

  • Are the load torque and output speed actually measured or reliably estimated?

  • Whether the working condition coefficient is based on the impact level and start and stop frequency

  • Check whether the speed ratio is the nearest standard value and check the output speed.

  • Whether the transmission efficiency is based on the model and series?

  • Whether the rated output torque of the reducer covers the calculated torque (including coefficient)

  • Whether the peak and starting torque are lower than the short-term overload upper limit

  • Does the inertia ratio meet the limits of the servo or general drive?

  • Are thermal power corrections, radial loads and installation methods checked item by item?

Conclusion: Matching is calculated, not estimated.

The key to matching the motor power to the reducer is the sequence: first calculate the torque and speed from the load, then inversely estimate the motor power from the speed ratio and efficiency, and then use the four items of inertia, starting torque, thermal power and radial load to do boundary checks. Estimated based on experience, any step may be repaired by broken teeth or burned motor after half a year of operation.

Hangzhou Weigao Transmission has long-term supporting product lines such as cycloidal pinwheel reducers , 、hard tooth surface reducers , worm gear reducers, gear reduction motors and TY series coaxial reducers, covering common working conditions such as transportation, mixing, lifting, and packaging. Provide the motor power, speed, load torque and working system, and the engineer can issue a complete Selection plan and reducer quotation for free . If you need to replace the imported brand, you can send a photo of the nameplate for model comparison. As a reducer manufacturer , we also support the customization of reducers with drawings and samples . If you want to calculate it yourself first, you can open Hangzhou Weigao Transmission's 'Motor Reducer Selection Configuration System' and enter the parameters to complete the reducer online Selection ; when the parameters are uncertain, you are also welcome to directly consult the reducer Selection。

FEEDBACK

What are the common problems with NGW42-25 planetary reducer base welding?

What kind of noise will the reducer produce if the box manufacturing accuracy is not up to standard?

Slewing Drive Solar Tracker Selection: Wind Load and Holding Torque

How to determine the displacement coefficient of the reducer gear: Examples of undercutting, tooth tip sharpening and center distance - Hangzhou Weigao Transmission

Which is more efficient, cycloidal pinwheel reducer or worm gear reducer?