Test the load before reducing the reducer Selection: on-site collection method of current, speed and load spectrum - Hangzhou Weigao Transmission
Publish Time: 2026-10-26 Origin: Site
Selection The calculation is wrong, probably because the input data is wrong.
The reducer Selection has errors. Most of them regard the nameplate parameters as on-site data. The motor nameplate power is the rated output capacity, not equal to the actual shaft power of the equipment; the rated torque on the sample is the long-term allowable value, not equal to the on-site peak value; the arithmetic mean taken casually is not equal to the equivalent load calculated based on fatigue damage. The starting point of 。the reducer Selection is not to turn over the sample, but to measure three sets of data: input power, output speed, and load spectrum of a complete working cycle.。
Five pieces of data to collect on site
project |
instrument |
Accuracy |
Recording method |
|---|---|---|---|
Three-phase voltage and current |
True RMS Clamp Meter/Power Analyzer |
Current ±2%, power 0.5~1 level |
Three phases are read simultaneously, and the stable segment is read 3 times |
Input power |
Power meter or inverter panel kW display |
Within ±2% |
Record by process |
Output speed |
Photoelectric/Hall tachometer + reflective sticker |
±1 r/min |
Test once per load section |
Shell and oil sump temperature |
Infrared thermometer (emissivity 0.95) |
±2℃ |
At the end of full load, measure the bearing position |
Number of starts and stops and single duration |
Counter or electronically controlled recording |
— |
24 consecutive hours or a full shift |
Estimating power by current method: the formula is simple, but there are many pitfalls
Three-phase power and load factor correction
Three-phase input power P 1 = √3·U·I·cosφ, multiplied by the motor efficiency to get the shaft power. The load factor is corrected according to β = (I 1 − I 0) ÷ (I n − I 0), where I 0 is the no-load current. Calculation example: 11 kW 4-pole motor, I n = 21.5 A, I 0 = 8.5 A, measured U = 385 V, I = 18.5 A, cosφ ≈ 0.79, then P 1 = 1.732×385×18.5×0.79 ≈ 9.7 kW. According to the efficiency of 0.88, the shaft power is about 8.6 kW, and the load rate β = (18.5−8.5)÷(21.5−8.5)≈ 77%. This is much more reliable than 'an 11 kW motor carries an 11 kW load', which is also a common mistake in matching motor power and reducer .
Three places that will distort the results
The no-load current accounts for 30% to 50% of the rated value. Directly dividing the measured current by the rated current will make the load smaller. When the load rate is lower than 40%, the power factor drops and the error is further amplified.
The output of the inverter is a PWM waveform, and the clamp meter reading of the average response is 15% to 25% lower. You must use a true RMS meter, or directly read the kW value on the inverter panel.
Only take an instantaneous value. The equipment is unloaded 90% of the time and fully loaded 10% of the time, so the instantaneous readings are not representative.
Experience boundary: The current method is more reliable in the load rate range of 50% to 100%; if it is below 40%, it is recommended to use a torque meter or power meter for direct measurement.
Load spectrum: convert equivalent torque using cubic power
Why is it cubic?
The fatigue life of gears and bearings is approximately inversely proportional to the cube of the load: if the torque exceeds the rated value by 10%, the service life will be reduced by approximately 30%. Therefore, the arithmetic mean cannot be taken for multi-stage working conditions, but the cubic mean must be used : T eq = [Σ T i ³·t i ÷ Σ t i ] 1/3。
Calculation example: comparison of three working conditions
load section |
Output torque |
Time proportion |
Torque³×Proportion |
|---|---|---|---|
Full load (delivery peak) |
1000N·m |
30% |
3.00×10⁸ |
Medium load (normal transportation) |
700N·m |
45% |
1.54×10⁸ |
Light load (no-load return trip) |
300N·m |
25% |
6.8×10⁶ |
total |
— |
100% |
4.61×10⁸ |
4.61×10⁸ When raised to the third power, T eq ≈ 773 N·m, while the arithmetic mean is only 690 N·m. According to the average value Selection, it is equivalent to overdrawing 12% of the torque margin in advance, and the life span difference is about 40%. If the speeds of each section are different, they should be weighted by the number of revolutions instead of time, because the life span is calculated by the number of revolutions: T eq = [Σ n i t i T i ³ ÷ Σ n i t i ] 1/3。
From the measured data back to the reducer Selection: three steps of reverse reasoning
step |
Calculation formula |
Main points |
|---|---|---|
speed ratio |
i = n 1 ÷ n2 |
Use actual measured input speed instead of motor synchronous speed. |
Output torque |
T 2 = 9550·P 2·i·η ÷ n1 |
Multi-stage transmission η takes 0.94~0.97 |
service factor |
f s = T peak ÷ T eq |
Combined with the working condition classification table, it falls between 1.0 and 2.0 |
Two more items: when the pulley and sprocket are directly mounted on the output shaft, the radial load must be converted to the midpoint of the shaft extension according to the cantilever structure; if the start and stop times exceed 10 times per hour, the heat capacity and braking impact must be included. The complete reducer Selection calculation chain is 'actual power → equivalent torque → service factor → thermal power check → radial load check'. Even if one link is missing, the wrong choice may be made.
Four common misunderstandings
If you use no-load current to estimate power, the result will inevitably be too small, so choose a smaller base size instead.
Use motor rated power instead of shaft power and ignore load rate and transmission chain losses.
Only the peak value is measured without looking at the time proportion. Selection is too large, and the long-term low-load operation efficiency and power factor are poor.
Measuring the current without remembering the time dimension and failing to produce a load spectrum is equivalent to not measuring it.
summary
SelectionThe upper limit of accuracy is determined by the input data. Two or three hours of on-site measurement - a true RMS clamp meter, an infrared thermometer, and a table recording each process can turn 'amplification based on experience' into a well-founded reducer Selection . After testing and selecting, you can often lower the base number by one level with the same reliability.
Hangzhou Weigao Transmission provides product lines such as hard tooth surface reducers, cycloidal pinwheel reducers, worm gear reducers, planetary reducers and gear reduction motors, etc., and can conduct Selection review and thermal power verification based on the measured load spectrum. As a reducer manufacturer , we can provide replacement solutions and free consultation for existing equipment . Welcome to send us the working condition data for verification.