Apron Feeder Gearbox Selection: Chain Pull, Shock Load and Service Factor

Publish Time: 2026-11-19     Origin: Site

An apron feeder is the one drive in a crushing circuit that gets sized on the wrong number. Running power for 600 t/h of limestone is about 17 kW, so a 37 kW motor looks generous and a 47 kN·m gearbox looks safe, until the planetary comes out with a cracked bearing. This guide sizes an apron feeder gearbox on the loads it actually sees: chain pull, breakaway, lump impact and motor locked-rotor torque, using one worked duty of 600 t/h over 20 m at 15°.

Why the Running Power Lies

Three events set the load, none of them in a throughput calculation. Breakaway: a feeder stopped under a full bed restarts against settled material, with rollers buried in compacted fines. Impact: a 400 kg lump falling 1.2 m delivers 450 J into the pans. Blockage: the drive runs into its torque limit and stays there until the chute is cleared. A unit chosen on 17 kW running power has no answer to any of the three.

Step 1: Throughput to Bed Load and Chain Speed

Capacity is a cross-section times speed: Q = 3,600 × b × h × v × ρ × φ = 3,600 × 1.60 × 0.60 × 0.13 × 1.55 × 0.86 = 599 t/h. Bed height is the material depth between skirts, not skirt height. The mass per metre follows: mm = Q / (3.6 v) = 600 / 0.468 = 1,282 kg/m, so 25.6 t of rock rides on 20 m of chain.

Input

Value

Basis

Throughput / density

600 t/h, 1.55 t/m³

Crusher feed, loose limestone

Pan width / bed height

1,600 mm / 600 mm

Three times the 500 mm top lump

Chain speed / fill factor

0.13 m/s / 0.86

Inside the 0.05–0.25 m/s band

Chain and pan mass

340 kg/m

1,800 mm pans, two 125 mm chains

Step 2: Chain Pull and Head Shaft Torque

Tractive force combines rolling resistance with lift. A combined coefficient f = 0.16 covers roller friction plus material drag on the skirts; clean rollers alone would be 0.05.

F = 9.81 × (mm + mc) × L × (f cos α + sin α) = 9.81 × 1,622 × 20 × (0.16 × 0.966 + 0.259) = 131.6 kN, with 49.2 kN friction and 82.4 kN lift. Running power is F × v = 17.1 kW.

Head sprocket geometry fixes speed and torque. With 18 teeth on 125 mm pitch, D = p / sin(180°/z) = 125 / sin 10° = 719.8 mm; n = 60 v / (π D) = 3.45 rpm; running torque T = F × D/2 = 47.3 kN·m.

Step 3: Keep Four Torques Separate

Running torque is the smallest of them. A settled bed adds 50%, a restart with a lump landing adds 30% more, and a 37 kW motor at 2.2 times locked-rotor torque can add far more than either.

Condition

Chain pull

Head shaft torque

Per chain

Running, steady bed

131.6 kN

47.3 kN·m

65.8 kN

Breakaway ×1.5

197.3 kN

71.0 kN·m

98.7 kN

Breakaway + impact ×1.3

256.5 kN

92.3 kN·m

128.3 kN

DOL locked rotor ×2.2

601 kN

216.4 kN·m

300 kN

VFD limit at 115% torque

314 kN

113 kN·m

157 kN

The last two rows argue for a controlled start. Two strands with 900 kN minimum breaking force give a safety factor of 900 / 128.3 = 7.0 on the mechanical peak. Under a direct-on-line start the same chain sees 300 kN per strand and falls to 3.0, below the 6.0 chain makers require for fatigue.

Step 4: Put the Service Factor in the Right Place

An apron feeder under a primary crusher is heavy shock duty, 10 h/day, which AGMA practice rates at a gearbox service factor of 1.75 (OEM tables run 1.50–2.00; state yours). On running torque: 47.3 × 1.75 = 82.9 kN·m, comfortably carried by a 100 kN·m unit. The 92.3 kN·m peak sits at 0.92 of nominal, inside the 2× momentary allowance. A 37 kW motor at 3.45 rpm delivers 98.3 kN·m rated, so frame and motor match.

The trap in applying the factor twice

Specify “SF 1.75 on motor nameplate” and demand becomes 98.3 × 1.75 = 172 kN·m — one frame up to 180 kN·m, about 40% more mass and cost. That is correct for DOL, where the motor can deliver 216 kN·m, but wrong once a VFD caps torque at 115%: the factor then belongs on running torque. Pick one rule and write it into the data sheet, or two suppliers will quote frames 40% apart.

Step 5: Thermal Rating and Output Bearing

Gear losses at 96% efficiency are 1.48 kW at 37 kW input. A housing of this class sheds roughly 36 W/K naturally, giving 41 K rise and an 81 °C sump at 40 °C ambient — above the 75 °C ceiling for predictable mineral oil life. A shaft fan lifts the coefficient to about 60 W/K: 24.7 K and a 65 °C sump. Dust matters more: assume 20% fin loss from clogging.

The head shaft bearing is not the constraint. It carries 131.6 / 2 + 15 = 80.8 kN, and a C = 320 kN spherical roller at 3.45 rpm gives L10 = (320/80.8)10/3 = 98.4 million revolutions, or 475,000 hours to ISO 281 — still 70,000 hours at the 143.3 kN peak.

Step 6: Backstop and Hollow Shaft Fit

A loaded 15° feeder runs backwards when de-energised. Reverse torque is 9.81 × 1,622 × 20 × 0.259 × 0.360 = 29.6 kN·m, doubling with a full discharge chute, so the backstop is rated 45 kN·m. Fit a backstop, not a brake, as the holding device. On the shrink disc, size slip torque at 1.5 × peak = 138 kN·m with the shaft tolerance band on the drawing — fretting here is the most common “gearbox” failure on apron feeders.

Specification Lines for the Enquiry

Item

Specification for this duty

Duty

600 t/h, 20 m, 15°, S1 with 10 starts/h

Output

3.45 rpm, 47.3 kN·m running / 92.3 kN·m peak

Gear unit

100 kN·m, i = 429, bevel-planetary, SF 1.75

Motor and start

37 kW IE3, VFD, torque limit 115%, 3 s ramp

Thermal

Shaft fan, 65 °C sump at 40 °C ambient

Quality and oil

GB/T 10095 grade 6–7, ISO 4406 18/16/13

Vibration baseline

ISO 20816-3 Group 2 rigid: 1.4 / 2.8 / 4.5 mm/s

Commissioning and the Monthly Walk

Record broadband velocity on the output bearing at full load and log it against those ISO 20816-3 boundaries; a new unit should land under 1.4 mm/s RMS. Then check chain slack on the return run (30–50 mm), skirt clearance (5–10 mm), pan bolt torque and sprocket wear at the pitch line. These four items catch most faults before they reach the teeth, and they are the cheapest gear reducer maintenance in the plant — one shift a month also gives early warning for gearbox troubleshooting long before noise appears.

Conclusion

Apron feeder gearbox sizing is not a power calculation. Convert throughput to bed load, bed load and incline to chain pull, then keep running, breakaway, impact and locked-rotor torque as separate numbers. Apply the 1.75 service factor to running torque only when a VFD caps the motor, size chain and backstop on the peak, and check thermal with clogged fins. Then the frame that looked oversized on 17 kW turns out to be exactly right.

Run your own figures through the online gearbox sizing system, and ask about SEW, NORD and Flender compatible replacements with matching mounting dimensions and shaft fit — retrofit onto an existing head shaft is where most apron feeder projects start.

FEEDBACK

Offshore Wind Vessel Gearbox Market 2027: Crane and Winch Drive Demand

How to check the carrying capacity of worm gear reducer: working condition coefficient, efficiency and Selection calculation example - Hangzhou Weigao Transmission

Lubrication and maintenance characteristics of B series industrial gearboxes

What are the common misunderstandings in B series gearbox maintenance?

Apron Feeder Gearbox Selection: Chain Pull, Shock Load and Service Factor