How to choose an industrial gearbox case: the differences between gray cast iron, ductile iron and welded cases - Hangzhou Weigao Transmission
Publish Time: 2026-10-23 Origin: Site
Industrial gearbox housing: The life of a set of gear pairs is often determined by this "skeleton"
In continuous heavy-load situations such as crushing, rolling, lifting, and grinding mills, the casing of industrial gearboxes is not just a shell: it must lock the center distance of the gear shaft system, withstand the meshing reaction force and impact, seal the oil, and dissipate heat. If the same set of gear pairs is installed in boxes made of different materials and structures, the lifespan may be doubled. The selection of below according to the four lines of material, structural form, working conditions and acceptance .the gearbox body will be clearly explained
Four things the box undertakes
Centering: The center distance and coaxiality of the bearing hole determine the tooth side clearance and contact spots. If it is deviated, it will degenerate into local stress. Loading: The cantilever load of the output shaft and the belt tension finally press the box and the foot with a counter moment. Seal: Split surface, oil seal position, and oil mark hole are the most common Heat dissipation and vibration reduction: The surface area of the box affects natural heat dissipation, and the material damping determines how much meshing vibration turns into causes of reducer oil leakage . abnormal noise of the reducer . Centering depends on precision, load-bearing and vibration damping depend on materials and stiffeners, and sealing depends on joint surface technology—only price and wall thickness, the latter three are out of the question.
Three commonly used materials: HT250, QT450-10 and ZG230-450
Gray cast iron accounts for more than 80% of the reducer casing, and the vibration-absorbing ability of flake graphite is the basis for its foothold. When ductile iron graphite forms into balls, the strength and toughness are greatly improved, the damping is slightly reduced, and the noise is 1~2dB higher; the cast steel is stronger and can be welded and repaired, at the expense of poor casting performance and doubled cost.
Trademark | tensile strength | Elongation | Features and applications |
|---|---|---|---|
HT250/HT300 | ≥250/300MPa | <1% | Good vibration damping and processability, large usage; medium-load general-purpose and heavy-duty large boxes |
QT450-10/QT500-7 | ≥450/500MPa | ≥10% / 7% | The impact resistance is about 3~5 times that of HT250, the wall thickness can be reduced by 20%~30%, and the cost is 10%~15% higher. |
ZG230-450 | ≥450MPa | ≥22% | It can be repaired by welding, but the damping is low, the noise is 5~8dB high, and the cost is about 2~3 times |
There are two numbers to watch: the tensile strength determines whether it will crack under impact, and the elastic modulus (gray iron 100~130GPa, ductile iron 160~180GPa) determines whether the axis will deflect after being stressed - the modulus of ductile iron is about 30% higher, and the deformation is smaller for the same wall thickness. This is the reason why equipment that frequently starts and stops tends to choose ductile iron boxes .
How to choose between cast box and welded box
The welded box is tailor-welded with Q235/Q345 steel plates. The plate thickness is usually 8~16mm, which is calculated as 80% of the cast wall thickness. Under the same weight, the stiffness is 20%~30% higher, the weight is 15%~25% lighter, the cost of small and medium-sized batches is saved by about 30%, and the delivery time is 30%~50% shorter than open mold casting. The shortcomings are also obvious: the damping of steel is much lower than that of cast iron, and noise is easier to transmit; the weld is a stress concentration area, and if deformation is not controlled well, the coaxiality of the bearing hole cannot be maintained. For welding boxes used in aggregate lines that operate continuously for 24 hours, it is not uncommon for micro-cracks to appear at the root of the weld in about half a year. The safe classification is: casting is used for continuous heavy load and batch finalized models; welding is used for extra large machine bases, single pieces and small batches, and those that require on-site repair welding. However, the key welds must be 100% flaw-detected, with a pass rate of not less than 95%, and stress must be relieved after welding.
Three boundaries for material selection according to working conditions
For stable load, transportation and mixing within 55kW, the vibration reduction and cost of HT250 are more suitable; for lifting mechanisms with frequent starts and stops, forward and reverse rotation, and obvious impact, choose QT450-10, which relies on 10% elongation to absorb impact; for heavy loads above 100kW and extra large single parts, consider QT500-7, ZG270-500 and Q345 welded structures respectively.
Five items for acceptance upon arrival, don’t just look at the brand number
project | Require | Consequences of failure |
|---|---|---|
Material certification | For the spectrum before the furnace or the test block with the furnace, write the complete brand name, do not write "cast iron" | Strength cannot be traced |
aging treatment | Artificial aging at 500~550℃, insulation for 4~6h, cooling ≤30℃/h; vibration aging for 48h can reduce residual stress by more than 60% | Deformation, hole system out of roundness |
internal defects | Magnetic particle or coloring flaw detection on the processed surface; no leakage of kerosene or 0.3~0.5MPa pressure holding for 30 minutes | Oil leakage from trachoma |
joint surface | Flatness ≤ 0.02mm/100mm²; 0.05mm feeler gauge insertion shall not exceed 1/3 of the width of the joint surface | Oil leakage on the split surface |
Hole system accuracy | Bearing hole H7, roundness ≤0.008mm, coaxiality ≤0.03mm, center distance ±0.05mm | Bearing heating, tooth surface eccentric load |
Two easy pitfalls
The first is to only recognize the brand name without asking about aging and flaw detection records. The internal stress has not been eliminated, and the installation accuracy will drift within a year no matter how good it is. The second is to attribute oil leakage to the oil product and oil seal. In fact, the flatness of the section surface and the bolt tightening sequence (diagonally divided into 3 steps) are more common. It is more effective to write it into the procurement technical agreement than to afterwards maintain the frequency reducer .
Conclusion: Determine the working conditions first, then the material, and finally the price.
When choosing the housing of an industrial gearbox , first look at the load properties and operating system, then decide on the material and structural form, and finally compare the price. No matter which material is used, the four inspections of aging, flaw detection, joint surface and hole system cannot be omitted.
Hangzhou Weigao Transmission Machinery Co., Ltd. provides cycloidal pinwheel reducers, hard tooth surface reducers, worm gear reducers, planetary reducers and gear reduction motors. The materials and structures of the boxes are matched according to the working conditions. As a reducer manufacturer , we provide free Selection for new production lines and imported model replacements: given the load, power, output speed and installation space, you can get model recommendations and material plans. If you need reducer Selection consultation or quotation, please contact Hangzhou Weigao Transmission - a local Hangzhou reducer manufacturer , which supports customization with drawings and samples.