How to determine the gear shaft of the reducer: root circle constraints, shaft fatigue check and separate Selection boundary - Hangzhou Weigao Transmission
Publish Time: 2026-11-09 Origin: Site
The gear and shaft are made into one part, and the tooth shape is milled directly on the shaft end, eliminating a set of key connections and a set of bearing positioning, and eliminating two or three processes in the assembly process. This structure is not uncommon in hard-tooth surface reducers , especially in situations where the output end cantilevers the pulley and requires high coaxiality. But there is a premise that is often ignored: the diameter of the shaft cannot exceed the diameter of the tooth root circle, otherwise the tooth root fillet cannot be formed. This constraint makes the design logic of the gear shaft completely different from that of ordinary shafts - this article is based on GB/T 1357-2008 'Cylinder Gear Module for General Machinery and Heavy Machinery', GB/T 1356-2001 'Standard Basic Rack Profile of Cylindrical Gear for General Machinery and Heavy Machinery' and GB/T 3480 series load capacity calculations, and the final gear shaft of a 15 kW reducer is completely walked through.
1. The gear shaft has one more dimension chain than the ordinary shaft.
1.1 Both ends of the dimension chain
For the output shaft of an ordinary cylindrical gear reducer, the shaft diameter d is determined by the bending and torsional strength of the shaft. The gear is mounted on the shaft and the two do not interfere with each other. The gear shaft integrates the two, and d is simultaneously stuck by the root circle diameter df: df = m(z 1 − 2.5). If df is less than d, the hob and gear grinding tools cannot retreat, the tooth root fillet ρ f = 0.38m has nowhere to be formed, and there is no transition step between the shaft and the tooth.
1.2 Two hard constraints
constraint | criterion | consequences of dissatisfaction |
|---|---|---|
Upper limit of shaft diameter | d < df = m(z 1 − 2.5) | The tool cannot give way, the tooth root fillet cannot be formed, and the tooth cannot be machined. |
Lower limit of shaft fatigue | σ = M e /W ≤ [σ −1 ], W = 0.1d3 | The shaft broke at the shoulder and the reducer was scrapped. |
Shaft shoulder fillet coordination | r ≤ ρ f = 0.38m | The stress concentration on the shaft shoulder exceeds the level of the tooth root, and the risk of tooth breakage is transferred to the shaft shoulder. |
These three items form a clamping interval: d must take a value between "not less than required by fatigue" and "less than the tooth root circle". If the interval is empty, the gear-shaft scheme will not be established, and only the separated gear and independent shaft can be returned. The following uses an example to illustrate how tight this interval is.
2. Calculation example: 15 kW reducer final gear shaft
2.1 Input parameters and coefficients
The calculation example takes a two-stage gear reduction motor to drive a belt conveyor, and the final stage pinion is made into a gear shaft.
project | symbol | value | unit | Basis and explanation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Motor power/speed | P 1 /n1 | 15/1 450 | kW/r/min | 4 pole asynchronous motor |
Overall speed ratio/total efficiency | i/n | 40/0.96 | — | Two-stage cylindrical gear |
Output speed/power | n 2 /P2 | 36.25/14.4 | r/min/kW | Output torque T 2 = 3 794 N·m |
Final gear ratio/pinion torque | u/T1 | 5/758.7 | —/N·m | Pinion speed 181.25 r/min |
load factor | K | 1.35 | — | Medium impact, GB/T 10063-1988 commonly used 1.2~2 |
Allowable contact/bending stress | [σ H ] / [σ F ] | 1 250/307 | MPa | σ Hlim = 1 500, σ Flim = 430, safety factor 1.2 / 1.4 |
Elasticity/node area coefficient | Z E / Z H | 189.8/2.5 | √MPa / — | Steel pairing, α = 20° |
Tooth width coefficient | ψd | 0.6 | — | Hard tooth surface, symmetrical arrangement |
2.2 Deducing the tooth geometry from the contact strength
According to GB/T 3480.2-2021, σ H = Z H ·Z E ·Z ε ·√(2·K·T 1·(u+1)/(b·d 12·u)). Taking Z ε = 1 as a conservative initial value, we can infer that d 1 ≥ 83.9 mm, that is, m ≥ 4.2 mm. According to GB/T 1357-2008, the priority series module is rounded to m = 5 mm, and then iterated back.
project | symbol | value | unit | illustrate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Number of teeth | z 1 /z2 | 20/100 | 齿 | u=5 |
Pitch circle diameter | d 1 /d2 | 100/500 | mm | d=mz |
center distance | a | 300 | mm | a = m(z 1+z 2)/2 |
Tooth width | b 1 /b2 | 68/60 | mm | b 2 = ψ d ·d 1, pinion width 8 mm to compensate for load concentration |
Tooth addendum/tooth root circle | d a / d f | 110/87.5 | mm | d a = m(z 1+2), d f = m(z 1−2.5) |
Tooth addendum/tooth root height | h a / h f | 5.0/6.25 | mm | GB/T 1356-2001: h a * = 1, c* = 0.25 |
Tooth root fillet | f | 1.9 | mm | Standard basic rack ρ fP = 0.38m |
Coincidence | ε α | 1.70 | — | Z ε = 0.875, Y ε = 0.690 |
Circular force/circular speed | Ft / v | 15 175 / 0.949 | N/m/s | F t = 2T 1/d1 |
Check results: contact stress σ H = 840 MPa, [σ H ] = 1 250 MPa, safety factor 1.49; tooth root bending stress σ F1 = 205 MPa (tooth shape coefficient Y Fa = 2.80, tooth root stress concentration coefficient Y Sa = 1.55), [σ F ] = 307 MPa, safety factor 1.50. The teeth are qualified.
3. The size of the shaft is the real difficulty of the gear shaft
3.1 Bending and torsion synthesis
The shaft part of the gear shaft bears both the output torque and the radial force of the cantilever pulley. Take the pulley radial force F r = 4 000 N, the cantilever length e = 100 mm, the bending moment M = 4×10 5 N·mm; the torque T 1 = 758 731 N·mm, converted according to the torque pulsation coefficient α = 0.6, the equivalent bending moment M e = √(M² + (αT)²) = 606 005 N·mm. The shaft material is 45 quenched and tempered steel, [σ −1 ] = 60 MPa.
From σ = M e /W ≤ [σ −1 ] and W = 0.1d 3, inversely calculate d ≥ (M e /(0.1[σ −1 ])) 1/3 = 46.6 mm. According to GB/T 2822-2005 R20 series, d = 50 mm, σ = 48.5 MPa, safety factor 1.24; pure torsional stress τ = 16T/(πd 3) = 30.9 MPa. At this time, d = 50 mm is much smaller than df = 87.5 mm, and the shoulder height (df − d)/2 = 18.8 mm is enough to clear the transition step.
3.2 Sensitivity of pinch intervals
Shaft diameter d (mm) | Section modulus W (mm³) | Bending stress σ (MPa) | Safety factor S | Relationship with tooth root circle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
45 | 9 112 | 66.5 | 0.90 | satisfy |
50 | 12 500 | 48.5 | 1.24 | satisfy |
56 | 17 562 | 34.5 | 1.74 | satisfy |
63 | 25 005 | 24.2 | 2.48 | satisfy |
In this example, the shaft has more margin because the final pinion speed is low, the torque is not large, and the output end is not a large cantilever. The real pressure occurs when the cantilever is lengthened:
Cantilever e (mm) | Bending moment M (N·mm) | Equivalent bending moment Me ( N·mm) | Required d ≥ (mm) | R20 optional d (mm) | Gear shaft feasibility |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
100 | 400 000 | 606 005 | 46.6 | 50 | established |
200 | 800 000 | 920 458 | 53.5 | 56 | established |
300 | 1 200 000 | 1 283 449 | 59.8 | 63 | established |
As e increases, the required shaft diameter increases simultaneously. The tooth root circle df also increases with the module, but the load-bearing requirements of the tooth limit the module and cannot be enlarged at will - the three chains of geometry, strength, and craftsmanship are mutually constraining. When the required shaft diameter reaches df, or when it is no longer cost-effective to increase the gear mass and tooth width after enlarging the module (the basic solution gear is about 3.6 kg, the outer diameter is 110 mm), a separate gear plus an independent shaft should be used instead, so that the shaft diameter can be independently determined.
4. Gear shaft Selection and troubleshooting steps
Check the structural prerequisites first: confirm that the working conditions are indeed suitable for the gear shaft - the output end does not need to replace the gear, the cantilever is not long, and the sealing requirements are high. According to the second section, the tooth geometry is determined by the contact strength, and the module is rounded to the GB/T 1357-2008 priority series. Then check the relationship between df and d, and confirm that d < m(z 1 − 2.5) is established, and the shoulder fillet r ≤ 0.38m. Then perform the bending and torsion synthesis of the shaft according to Section 3, check that d ≥ the required value, and check whether there is a feasible intersection between d and df. Finally, the gear and shaft results are reported at the same time, and sufficient safety factors must be left for both.
There are two other points that are easy to miss. First, the teeth are carburized and quenched according to the hard tooth surface, and the shaft needs to maintain toughness. The heat treatment requirements of the two conflict. The process window of the gear shaft is much narrower than that of the separate type. When purchasing, the hardness and core requirements of the shaft must be clearly defined. Secondly, the tooth shape and force mechanism of the worm gear reducer and the cycloidal pinwheel reducer are different. The module rounding and tooth root fillet rules of the gear shaft cannot be directly applied: the worm gear is implemented in accordance with GB/T 10085-2018 and GB/T 10088-2018, and the cycloid pinwheel is assessed in accordance with GB/T 36491-2018.
5. Conclusion
The value of the gear shaft is to save processes and improve coaxiality, but the price is that the shaft diameter is stuck by the tooth root circle df. The essence of the design is to find a clamping interval: the diameter of the shaft is not less than what is required for bending and torsion synthesis, and is smaller than what is allowed by the tooth root circle. In the calculation example, the final stage of the 15 kW two-stage reducer is m = 5, z 1 = 20, df = 87.5 mm, the shaft part d = 50 mm, the tooth contact and bending safety factors are 1.49 and 1.50 respectively, and the shaft part is 1.24. The solution is established. When the cantilever is lengthened to 300 mm, the required shaft diameter rises to 59.8 mm, which is still within the range; if it is pushed upwards, the advantage of the gear shaft will be offset by the increase in weight of the gear. At this time, the separated structure is a more stable choice. Hangzhou Weigao Transmission provides Selection accounting of the hard tooth surface reducer and gear shaft structure, which can be reviewed item by item according to the above steps.